Gas Station Slip and Fall Settlements

Compensation for Victims of Slip and Fall Accidents at Chicago Gas Stations

Gas station slip and fall settlements often hinge on how the incident occurred and whether owners and managers met their legal duty to keep customers safe. 

At Slip & Fall Injury Lawyers, our personal injury attorney team helps Chicago victims of falls at a gas station or convenience store caused by a slippery floor, spilled fuel, worn mats, snow, or ice. We are experienced in proving negligence and pursuing compensation that covers medical expenses, lost income, and future care.

What Is the Average Settlement for a Slip and Fall at a Gas Station?

The average settlement in slip and fall cases involving gas stations is about $816,153, with a median of $250,000. Reported outcomes span a value range from $25,000 to $12,264,302.

Several factors can influence the value of a slip and fall claim, including:

• Injury severity and permanence
• Complete medical costs and future care
• Lost income and reduced earning capacity
• Notice to the owner of the hazard and a delay in cleanup
• Cause of the slip and fall incident (fuel spill, ice, worn mats, uneven pavement)
• Missing or poorly placed wet floor sign
• Prior complaints or similar incidents
• Quality of photos, video, and witness statements
• Comparative fault arguments
• Insurance company posture and venue/jury tendencies

Example Settlements Following Slips and Falls Due to Wet Floors, Poor Lighting, and Other Hazards at Gas Stations

$12.26M Verdict (High–Low $6M) After Slick Curb Fall Causes Brain Injury

Annette Ritzmann slipped on a dark, slick spot under a gas station’s covered awning and fell forward, striking her chin. She alleged the convenience store and gas station were on notice—employees admitted prior complaints about the slippery spot—and failed to place cones or warnings. The judge ruled she was not negligent. 

Ritzmann claimed a traumatic brain injury with cognitive deficits, balance issues, fatigue, and a developing seizure disorder, requiring extensive therapies and significant future care. Her business declined, and she suffered a significant loss of income. The jury awarded $12,264,302, subject to a high–low agreement of $6,000,000/$1,500,000.

$1.75M Settlement for Ice Hazard Allegedly Caused by Leaky Gutter

Lorilynn Hassett slipped on ice on the gas station premises and claimed a leaky gutter directed runoff to the pump area, where it froze. Plaintiff pointed to a repair work order submitted weeks before the incident that was never completed. The defense argued the condition was open and obvious and raised comparative negligence. 

Hassett alleged the fall aggravated preexisting L4-5/L5-S1 disc herniations, leading to an L4-5 discectomy, fusion, and later a spinal cord stimulator, each followed by therapy. She sought lost earnings, extensive future life-care, and pain and suffering. The parties reached a $1,750,000 pretrial settlement.

$1.64M Jury Verdict After Icy Walkway Fall at Convenience Store Entrance

Andre Turner slipped on the ice directly in front of a gas station convenience store. Plaintiff sent a preservation letter, but surveillance was not saved; the court issued a spoliation instruction. The out-of-possession landlord was dismissed; the case proceeded against the manager. 

Turner sustained multiple ligament tears in his right ankle and underwent reconstructive surgery, extensive debridement, and fixation, followed by lengthy physical therapy. He did not return to work and was recommended for future procedures. The jury found the manager negligent and awarded $1,637,500 (medical costs, lost income, future care, and pain and suffering).

$775K Settlement After Rainwater Pooling Leads to Knee Fracture

Ronald Williams slipped just after stepping off an entry mat inside a gas station when rainwater allegedly pooled by a side entrance. Employees placed wet floor signs only after the incident; former staff testified that pooling occurred after heavy rains and was known to management. The defense cited alcohol use and extensive preexisting conditions. 

Williams sustained a displaced, comminuted periprosthetic fracture near a prior knee replacement and underwent multiple revision surgeries and lengthy rehab, later suffering additional falls and complications. Before the trial, the self-insured gas station owner paid $775,000.

$195,832 Net Award After Slip on Painted No-Parking Stripe

After a thunderstorm, Tracy DeMoss slipped on a painted yellow “no parking” line while walking from the pump area to the store. She argued the paint lacked a slip-resistant additive, and her expert’s testing showed a much lower coefficient of friction than adjacent surfaces; the defense claimed adequate materials and inattentiveness. 

DeMoss underwent an ACDF at C6-7 and arthroscopic repair of a right rotator cuff/labrum, with additional pain-management care. The jury awarded $489,559 but found her 60% at fault, reducing the award to $195,832. The case illustrates how surface materials at a gas station can drive settlements and comparative fault outcomes.

What Damages Can Victims Recover in Slip and Fall Claims?

Damages in a slip and fall claim cover both financial losses and the personal impact of the accident. Economic damages include medical bills (ER care, imaging, surgery, therapy) and future treatment, plus lost wages and reduced earning capacity if the injury keeps you off the job. You can also claim out-of-pocket expenses (transportation, medications, braces). 

Non-economic damages address pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life from the slip and fall incident. When property owners breach a legal duty, a personal injury attorney can help you prove that and recover fair compensation.

How Slip & Fall Injury Lawyers Can Help You Recover Compensation From Negligent Property Owners

The team at Slip & Fall Injury Lawyers is here to help you build a strong claim from start to finish. 

We investigate the incident, gather video, incident reports, cleaning logs, and witness statements, and compare them to the gas station owner’s legal duty. If a wet floor or a missing/poorly placed wet floor sign caused your injury, we work to establish the negligent party. 

We document medical expenses, future care, and lost income, then present a clear demand for compensation. If insurers stall, we litigate and pursue a settlement that reflects your full losses. 

Book a Free Consultation

If a slip and fall accident at a gas station or convenience store left you with medical bills and lost wages, we can help. Speak with a Chicago slip and fall attorney to learn about the value of your claim. We investigate the incident, preserve video, and work to prove negligence, aiming for a favorable outcome in your case. Contact us for a free consultation!