Parking Lot Slip and Fall Settlements

Compensation for Victims of Slip and Fall Accidents at Chicago Parking Lots

Parking lot slip and fall settlements can vary widely, but they often reflect the seriousness of the injuries and the negligence that caused them. At Slip & Fall Injury Lawyers, we represent individuals in Chicago who have suffered slip and fall injuries due to hazards like cracked pavement, icy surfaces, poor lighting, and other dangerous conditions. 

If a property owner’s negligence caused your fall, you may have the right to seek compensation through a slip and fall claim. Our slip and fall attorneys work to secure a fair settlement so clients can focus on recovery while we handle the legal process. Schedule a free consultation to seek legal advice!

What Is the Average Settlement for a Parking Lot Slip and Fall Case?

The average settlement for a slip and fall accident in a parking lot is around $500,600, with a median of $250,000. Reported slip and fall case values range widely, from as low as $3,523 to as high as $5,000,000.

Several factors influence how much a slip and fall case settlement may be worth, including:

• The severity and permanence of the injuries
• The cost of medical treatment and future care needs
• Whether the fall accident caused lost wages or reduced earning ability
• Evidence that the property owner knew about the fall hazard and failed to act
• The clarity of liability and strength of supporting evidence
• How the insurance company responds to the claim
• Whether the case is settled or goes to trial

Example Slip and Fall Parking Lot Settlements

$3.6 Million Slip and Fall Accident Settlement After Below-the-Knee Amputation

William Strauss, 59, slipped on snow and ice while attempting to gain traction under his vehicle. He suffered a severe ankle fracture that, despite multiple surgeries, led to a below-the-knee amputation in 2024. 

Strauss sued the property owner for failing to remove snow and ice properly. His engineering expert testified that the property owner was aware of the hazard and failed to act. The defense claimed compliance with snow removal standards. After extensive treatment–including multiple surgeries, long-term infection management, and prosthesis fitting–Strauss’s serious injuries rendered him unable to work. 

He sought damages for pain and suffering, lost wages, and extensive future medical needs. Following three days of trial, a $3.6 million settlement was reached through mediation.

$3.24 Million Jury Verdict for TBI in Premises Liability Case

Kimberly Taherian, 45, slipped and fell on ice in a CVS parking lot, suffering a traumatic brain injury (TBI), concussion, and head laceration. 

She sued the property owner and snow removal contractor, alleging failure to maintain safe conditions. The contractor settled confidentially before trial; only the property owner proceeded to court. Taherian experienced ongoing cognitive issues, including memory loss and an inability to return to work. Her experts estimated lost earnings between $1.08 and $1.49 million. 

The jury awarded $3,242,737, including $1,242,737 in economic damages and $2 million in non-economic damages, for pain, suffering, and permanent cognitive impairment.

$3 Million Wrongful Death Settlement After Fall Leaves Victim Quadriplegic

Nicholas Caldarola, 77, slipped on ice in a ShopRite parking lot and became quadriplegic. He died three months later. 

His estate sued multiple defendants, including the property owner, store operator, and snow removal company, alleging improper snow management and drainage issues that led to refreezing. The estate claimed Caldarola endured months of pain, multiple surgeries, infections, and mental anguish before his death. The defense focused on assigning blame among themselves. 

The fatal slip and fall case was resolved pretrial through mediation for a total of $3 million, with contributions from all involved insurance carriers.

$2.1 Million Parking Lot Settlement After Slip on Snow-Covered Ice 

Debra Knab, 51, slipped on a hidden patch of ice beneath snow in a parking lot owned by her employer’s landlord. 

She stated in her slip and fall claim that the lot’s depression had been a known hazard since 1999 and had not been cleared as required by contract. Knab suffered multiple herniated discs and underwent spinal fusion, hardware removal, and implantation of a spinal cord stimulator. She claimed permanent disability and ongoing pain. 

The case was settled pretrial, with $2.05 million paid by the property owner’s insurer and $50,000 from the snow contractor’s insurer, totaling $2.1 million.

$1.9 Million Parking Lot Settlement

Anthony Neonakis, 30, slipped on ice while exiting a vehicle. He suffered a herniated disc and spinal nerve compression, requiring surgery after years of physical therapy and pain management. His slip and fall injuries caused ongoing pain, reduced mobility, and permanent inability to return to work. 

Neonakis sued the property owners, alleging failure to treat icy conditions. The defense argued the fall occurred shortly after snowfall, limiting their liability. Before trial, the parties reached a $1.9 million settlement, with $1 million from the primary insurer and $900,000 from excess coverage.

$1.84 Million Settlement for Steamfitter With Long-Term Ankle Damage

Christopher Hayes, 29, a steamfitter, slipped on black ice and fractured his right ankle. He sustained multiple torn ligaments and nerve entrapment, requiring surgery and extensive therapy. Hayes alleged that the parking lot was not properly maintained and that the property owner should have been aware of the icy conditions. 

Hayes claimed permanent disability, a persistent limp, and future surgeries, including ankle fusion. He sought over $11 million in future lost wages. The defense argued that he ignored medical advice and failed to mitigate damages. Before trial, the parties reached a $1,837,500 settlement.

$1.8 Million Slip and Fall Case Settlement for CRPS After Black Ice Fall

Miriam Delgado, 44, slipped on black ice under her car in a parking lot. She sustained serious injuries, including knee meniscus tears, carpal tunnel aggravation, elbow damage, and a neck disc herniation. Following several surgeries, she developed complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), leaving her unable to work and dependent on pain treatment. 

Delgado alleged poor snow removal and failure to inspect the premises. Defendants denied liability and disputed the CRPS diagnosis. Before trial, the case settled for $1.8 million, with $1.525 million paid by Stony Brook’s insurer and $275,000 by the property owner’s insurer.

$1.65 Million Jury Award for Tenant Who Slipped on Icy Ramp

Jose Carrero, 55, slipped on an icy parking lot ramp near his apartment. He suffered a comminuted wrist fracture requiring surgery, and later developed post-traumatic arthritis and carpal tunnel syndrome. His slip and fall injuries caused long-term pain, loss of function, and the need for future surgery. 

Carrero sued the lot owner, Nicola Dedaj, for failing to maintain safe conditions. Dedaj denied responsibility and claimed the plaintiff exaggerated his injuries. The jury found Dedaj 100% liable and awarded $1,649,000, including $1.35 million for future pain and suffering.

$1.5 Million Slip and Fall Parking Lot Settlement for Delivery Driver Injured on Ice

A 52-year-old delivery driver slipped on ice in an unlit supermarket lot around 1:00 a.m. There were no witnesses, but the plaintiff reported the incident the same day. He suffered a fractured rib and aggravation of pre-existing low back arthritis, which he claimed left him permanently disabled. He alleged the lot was unsafe due to poor lighting and a lack of snow and ice removal. 

The defense disputed the fall and argued any injuries were unrelated to the slip. The parties reached a $1.5 million settlement, covering medical expenses, lost earnings, and permanent disability claims.

$1.28 Million Verdict for Retail Worker After Slip and Fall Accident

Michael White, a retail worker in his 40s, slipped on untreated ice in an apartment lot. 

A tenant had texted the property manager 90 minutes before the incident, warning that the lot was “a sheet of ice,” but no action was taken. White fractured his ankle and underwent multiple surgeries. He continues to suffer pain, impaired mobility, and may require future ankle fusion or replacement. 

The jury found the property owner and manager 94% liable and the snow contractor 6% liable. White was awarded $1,275,900 in total damages.

$1.1 Million Slip and Fall Parking Lot Settlement for DMV Employee Injured on Ice

Kim Wilford, 55, slipped on ice while walking through a parking lot to her job at the DMV. She suffered spinal disc herniations, cervical and lumbar radiculopathy, and chronic pain. Her back injury treatment included injections, radiofrequency ablations, and physical therapy. 

Wilford claimed permanent disability and sought damages for lost income, medical expenses, and pain. The defense argued that a sudden refreeze occurred after snow removal. The case settled for $1,100,000 before trial.

$990K Settlement for Senior Who Suffered Brain Injury in Plaza Lot

Edna Picciotto, 74, slipped on ice in a parking lot and struck her head. She suffered a skull fracture and subdural hematoma requiring a craniotomy. Her personal injury attorney cited poor drainage, persistent icy conditions, and a prior fall in the same location. Picciotto claimed permanent cognitive impairment, loss of balance, and the need for full-time residential care. 

The defense disputed whether the hematoma was caused by the fall. Before trial, the parties reached a $990,000 settlement, which covered her past medical bills, future care needs, and pain and suffering.

$989K Jury Award for Double Fall in Apartment Lot

Donald Phillips, 57, fell twice in the same apartment parking lot. His slip and fall claim stated the falls were caused by sand and debris on painted lines, leading to a fractured hip and later a broken knee, both requiring surgery. Phillips now uses a walker and claims permanent limitations.

The defense argued the lot was safe and pointed to Phillips’ pre-existing health issues. The jury assigned 60% fault to the management company, 20% to the property owner, and 20% to Phillips. He was awarded $989,361.62, reduced to $686,648.95 after comparative fault.

$835K Settlement for Salesperson Injured in Mall Parking Lot

Jean Szanyi, 51, slipped on snow in the parking lot of a Dollar Tree store and suffered a fractured tailbone and spinal injuries. She stated in her slip and fall claim that the lot had not been plowed despite several inches of snow. Szanyi underwent spinal decompression, discectomy, and laminectomies, and alleged permanent disability and chronic pain. 

She sued the store, property owners, and snow contractors. The contractor argued it wasn’t required to plow until snow reached two inches. The case settled during mediation for $835,000, with $500,000 paid by the snow removal contractor and $335,000 by the other defendants.

$829K Jury Award for Ice-Related Tibia Fracture and Infection

Gladys Baldeon, 42, slipped on black ice in a strip mall parking lot. She fractured her tibia, required external fixation, and later developed a severe infection. She now walks with a cane and receives in-home care. The snow removal contractor claimed the lot was still being cleared when the fall occurred. 

The property owner claimed it had fulfilled its duties by hiring the contractor. The jury found the owner 60% liable, the snow removal contractor 30%, and Baldeon 10%. The total award was $829,000, reduced to $746,100 after comparative fault.

$800K Slip and Fall Parking Lot Settlement for Deliveryman With Shoulder and Spine Injuries

Angel Reyes, 34, slipped on ice in a bus depot parking lot and injured his shoulder, neck, and back. He underwent two surgeries, including shoulder arthroscopy and spinal discectomy, and was later diagnosed with radiculopathy and major depressive disorder. 

Reyes claimed the property was not properly treated after a storm, despite prior notice of unsafe conditions. He sued the property owners, manager, and tenants. The defense argued the lot was safe and his injuries predated the fall. The case settled before trial for $800,000, paid by the defendants’ primary insurance policy.

$775K Parking Lot Settlement for Clerk Injured After Fall on Untreated Ice

Karen Gleeson, 42, slipped on ice while walking to work and fell into a truck’s running board. She suffered a concussion and herniated cervical discs requiring multiple procedures, including spinal fusion and discectomy. 

Gleeson alleged the property had not been salted despite prior snow and known runoff refreezing overnight. A responding police officer also slipped at the same location. The defense argued she should have noticed the ice and claimed her injuries were pre-existing. Before trial, the parties reached a $775,000 settlement to resolve the slip and fall lawsuit.

$694K Jury Award for Retired Electrician Injured After Fall Near Hotel Lot

Arthur Gordon, 65, slipped and fell into a brook while walking from an overflow parking lot to a hotel where he was attending a union meeting. His slip and fall claim stated the hotel failed to provide adequate parking and a safe walking path, while the shopping center failed to secure the hazardous area. 

Gordon sustained multiple fractures, infections, and long-term complications, requiring several surgeries. The jury found the hotel 75% liable and Gordon 25% comparatively at fault. He was awarded $694,229.76, later reduced to $520,672.32, including $400,000 for pain and suffering and $135,000 for his wife’s per quod claim.

What Damages Can Victims Recover From Negligent Property Owners?

After a slip and fall incident, victims may be able to recover both economic and non-economic damages, depending on the circumstances and severity of the injury. 

Economic damages cover financial losses such as medical expenses for emergency care, hospitalization, ongoing treatment, and physical therapy. If the injury forces you to miss work, you may also seek compensation for lost wages and, in more serious slip and fall cases, loss of future earning potential. 

Non-economic damages address the personal impact of the slip and fall. These damages include pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and the overall decline in quality of life following severe injuries like broken bones or traumatic brain injuries. A slip and fall attorney can evaluate your case and seek a fair settlement that reflects the full extent of your losses.

How a Slip and Fall Attorney From Our Team Can Help

Following a parking lot slip and fall accident, proving liability and recovering fair compensation can be challenging without legal guidance. 

A slip and fall attorney from our team will investigate the incident, gather evidence such as surveillance footage, witness statements, and maintenance records, and determine whether the property owner knew—or should have known—about the hazard. 

We handle all communication with the property owner’s insurance company, build a strong claim, and push for a fair settlement that covers your medical bills, lost income, and other damages. If the insurance company refuses to settle fairly, we’re prepared to file a slip and fall lawsuit. 

Our goal is to recover compensation while you focus on healing from your slip and fall injuries.

Secure Expert Legal Representation 

If you’ve suffered a fall injury at someone else’s property due to unsafe conditions, having experienced legal representation can make all the difference. At Slip & Fall Injury Lawyers, we understand what it takes to prove the property owner’s negligence and pursue maximum compensation. 

Our Chicago slip and fall accident attorneys know how insurance companies operate and won’t let them undervalue your slip and fall settlement. From gathering evidence to negotiating with the property owner’s insurance company, we handle every part of your slip and fall case. 

Let us fight for the fair compensation you deserve. Seek legal advice by scheduling a free consultation!